Quite simply, because sometimes it’s really necessary! If your child is about to hit another child, jump on the dog or smash granny’s expensive vase, there are only two words that will do. NO or STOP. Not shouted (because kids really don’t listen if they’re shouted at), but said very loudly and very seriously. Either word is absolutely fine. No (and stop) very clearly tells the child that what they’re about to do (or have just done) is categorically not acceptable. It is short, brief and to the point and absolutely cannot be misunderstood. In a heated/dangerous moment, you don’t want to confuse the children with a lengthy sentence. You have to think about the quickest way to stop something. Above anything else, the safety of your child, other children, animals and precious objects, are vitally important. Safety trumps *anything* in my opinion. That’s why I put it first in my five step tantrum plan (though – this isn’t just relevant to tantrums – but rather any difficult behaviour):
As with my meme above. NO is absolutely fine in the ‘Safety’ section……BUT once safety is secured, it’s time to work through everything else and once the child is calm – then you need to explain. You can’t just leave it at no.
When Shouldn’t You Say No?
When there is no real need to. That looks different for everyone. Unfortunately we are quite conditioned to say no to children a lot, but that subconscious response is often totally unnecessary (I’ve written about this before HERE). So, if you want to say no, my best advice is to first ask yourself “why am I saying no?”. If there is a legitimate reason and you really believe that saying no is the right thing, then it’s OK to say it! Just support and explain and make sure you tell them what you want them to do instead. That explanation is key. Tell them what you want them to do, otherwise they just don’t know. But, as with the safety situation above, there is no use telling them what you want them to do if they are mid tantrum/sulk/screaming. Wait for them to calm first. If they are already calm – you could focus straight away on telling them what you want them to do instead (“stroke the cat’s ears, not her tail” etc..).
What about Yes Spaces?
I’m pretty confused about the idea of yes spaces and why people think they are a gentle parenting thing. A yes space is an environment where the child can do whatever they want, without the adult saying no. Yes, it is a lovely idea and I’d advise all parents to reduce any need to say no, by removing anything that they don’t want children to touch and so on (and questioning the need to say no)……but I think yes spaces do children a disservice. It’s not wrong to say no, but it is wrong to remove any learning from the children. It also feels a lot to me like trying to avoid dealing with big emotions from little people. They can cope with no, if it is said mindfully and effectively (see above) and we support any upset. No is everywhere in life. A little learning in a safe and supportive environment is great preparation for that. Don’t be afraid to say it!
For more on saying no, coping gently with difficult child behaviour and the best way to communicate for effective discipline, see my Gentle Discipline Book (in the UK, USA, Canada, Australia and Rest of the World).
p.s: Come and chat with me on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram
Or watch my videos on YouTube
You can also sign up for my free parenting newsletter HERE.